Nostalgic gifts from home 
Search
Step 1
Pick your crate
Step 2
Select your items
Step 3
Review and confirm

3 Item Gift Crate

Create the perfect gift. Select any three of the delicious New York bakery items below. We will package them up in a stunning fire-branded, wood gift crate, along with free imported Italian Torrone.

New York Rainbow Cookies Gift Box

New York Rainbow Cookies Gift Box

If you are from New York you more than likely know about the famous Rainbow Cookie. Rainbow Cookies have adorned the bakeries in New York for years and have become a favorite of those who have moved on from our beloved state. Ours have a moist, dense, delectable almond flavor that bursts on your palate. Our authentic rainbow cookies are made with tremendous care as three layers of cake are separated by raspberry jam and tactfully covered with bittersweet chocolate. This is one of our favorite products here at Famighetti due to its flavor, texture and New York Nostalgia. Makes a great gift. 

Have them delivered anywhere! 
New: Rainbow cookies are now offered uncut to retain almond flavor & moisture. Just slice & eat! 
To order Pre-Cut cookies please click on "weight" scroll down tab. 
Number of Cookies per pound: 1.25 lb: 28-30,  2.5 lbs: 56-60, etc
Packaging: Ordering your rainbow cookies from nypantry.com means your receiving your cookies in climate controlled packaging and they will not be crushed by the time your recipient receives them. We ship them secured yet presented beautifully!
 
NOTE: most shipments go out same business day they are ordered;  however during busy seasons please allow one business day after purchase for processing orders.  
Black & White Cookies

Black & White Cookies

Walk into just about any bakery in New York and you will find the beloved Black & White Cookie. For New Yorkers the Black & White cookie adorned the pastry & cookie platter after dinner at just about every holiday meal. For others it is a favorite treat you pick up at the local bakery. Ours are the traditional large size and made with the absolute finest ingredients!  We start with a soft cream cake base and top it by hand with a vanilla fondant and rich semi sweet chocolate fudge. Makes a great nostalgic gift for a friend. 

5 large cookies / 1.5lbs (approx weight) 

3 large cookies / 1lbs (approx weight) 

Individually wrapped for fresh delivery!

Ingredients: Enriched Wheat Flour (Ferrous Sulfate, Niacin, Thiamine, Mononitrate, Riboflavin, Folic Acid), Sugar, Whole Eggs, Soybean Oil, Whey (Milk), Cocoa Powder, Corn Starch, Leavening (Sodium Aluminum Phosphate, Sodium Bicarbonate , Aluminum Sulfate, Wheat Gluten, Soy Lecithin, Salt, Mono & Digycerides, Natural and Artificial Flavors, Potassium Sorbate (to retain freshness) may contain one or more of the following FD&C colors, Yellow #5 & 6, Red #3 & 40, Blue #1

Please note: On rare occasions Famighetti's may substitute large black and white cookies for the smaller size yet retain the correct weight you ordered. We always will make sure you or your gift recipient gets more than you purchased!!

Some shipments go out same business day they are ordered; however please allow 1 business day after purchase for processing orders. 

Scroll to top